I'm Ragetti in CaptTreasureTroveTi's PotC Claimers’ Crew!
I'm the Quaffle in sasumonkey's Harry Potter Crew!
I'm Professor Quirrell in racheyrae's Harry Potter Crew!

I strongly believe that Doctor Lawrence Gordon (Cary Elwes) from Saw 1 is alive, and that he will return in Saw 6! Not only that, but there is also a real possibility that Gordon is an accomplice of Jigsaw, or that Jigsaw is in fact Gordon's accomplice and Gordon has been behind the series from the very beginning. Don't believe me? Read on...

(NOTE: I think the Saw movies beyond Saw 1 are stupid. Gordon is one of my two favourite characters from Saw 1, however, and I'm very excited by his possible return.)

*** THE PROOF ***
(Evidence I have collected from various sources)

- Firstly, there is no evidence to suggest that Gordon is even dead; his only injury was his sawn-off foot, and, being a surgeon, he could easily treat that until he got out of the room at the end of Saw 1.

- All throughout Saw 1, Gordon never recognised Jigsaw's 'corpse', despite the fact that Jigsaw was his patient at the hospital.

- Also in Saw 1, Gordon ignored the fact that Jigsaw's 'corpse's tape player didn't have a tape in it. Gordon knew that Jigsaw's other victims were given tapes to play, and given his very critical observations regarding their situation, he would not normally have missed this detail.

- Adam told Gordon that Detective Tapp paid him to follow and photograph Gordon, and Adam described Tapp as "a tall black guy with a scar around his neck." Gordon immediately recognised Tapp from the description, even though Gordon had never seen Tapp with the scar - unless Gordon was the one who gave it to him.

- When Adam was looking at the pictures of Gordon's family, Gordon said something like "I'm never in the picture because I'm always the one holding the camera." Gordon has NEVER been in the picture (the movie) AT ALL since Saw 1. The most we've seen of him is his rotting foot chained to the wall.

- When victims pass their tests, Jigsaw says "So many people are ungrateful to be alive. But not you. Not anymore." He said this to Amanda when she passed her test, which made sense. However he also said it to Adam as he locked him in the room at the very end of Saw 1, which doesn't make sense at all as Adam failed his test. A possible solution is that Jigsaw actually said it to Gordon at a later time, and the filmmakers played it over the end of Saw 1 to confuse us.

- In Saw 2, Michael was shown a video of a cloaked figure inserting a key behind Michael's eye. The figure was limping on its right foot; the same foot that Gordon sawed off.

- Throughout the Saw series, there are various traps that require incredibly advanced medical knowledge to construct and maintain, such as the angel trap, the poles impaled through the couple, the rings attached all over a man and the key behind Michael's eye. Jigsaw was a mechanic and would not have the required medical expertise; Gordon, however, would.

- Jigsaw and his accomplices also had access to a seemingly never-ending medical supply; everything from medicine to wheelchairs to heart rate monitors to hospital beds. They would need someone on the inside of a hospital to smuggle all this out - Gordon.

- At the end of Saw 1, Gordon went to get help and Adam asked if they're going to be okay. Gordon replied "I'd never lie to you." Then, in Saw 3, Amanda returned to Adam and said "I'm going to help you," then proceeded to kill Adam. This could be Gordon honoring his promise to Adam and either thinking that killing Adam is the same as saving him, or Amanda betrayed Gordon just as she betrayed Jigsaw.

- At the start of Saw 4, Jigsaw explained to Hoffman on his tape that he was "probably the last man standing." Jigsaw was always 100% sure of the outcomes of the situations he created and would therefore not say something so ambiguous, unless he was deliberately alluding, in this instance, to the fact that someone else in his reign was alive, i.e. Gordon.

- Also in Hoffman's tape, Jigsaw promised that Hoffman would be tested. As of the end of Saw 5, Hoffman is apparently the only major apprentice of Jigsaw left alive and is also as yet untested by Jigsaw. Then who can test him? There are two real candidates - Jill, Jigsaw's ex-wife, and Gordon. Jill is the most likely, since she was given a tape and a box by Jigsaw - but since when do the Saw writers go with the most likely solution? Isn't the whole point of Saw the incredible plot twists? What would be the point in taking the most easy and obvious way out and making Jill the one behind it all?

Dr. Lawrence Gordon, one of two 'victims' from the very first film, since then unseen, an accomplice of Jigsaw?

Or even better, behind the entire series from the very beginning?

Now THERE's a twist.